It is truly incredible but I am approaching fast my fiftieth book review! I never predicted my blog would last so long. To celebrate the fact that some awesome people come here and actually read them I am going to let my fantastic followers and other visitors to decide which novel should be read and review by me as the 50th. On the right there is a poll with all four options included - just vote and I will do as I am told, remaining your humble servant etc. etc. ;)
Ok, now let me present the options for the 50th review (I include short descriptions of all books from Amazon.com to save you the bother) :
1. Umberto Eco's Foucault's Pendulum.
From Library Journal:
Student of philology in 1970s Milan, Casaubon is completing a thesis on the Templars, a monastic knighthood disbanded in the 1300s for questionable practices. At Pilades Bar, he meets up with Jacopo Belbo, an editor of obscure texts at Garamond Press. Together with Belbo's colleague Diotallevi, they scrutinize the fantastic theories of a prospective author, Colonel Ardenti, who claims that for seven centuries the Templars have been carrying out a complex scheme of revenge. When Ardenti disappears mysteriously, the three begin using their detailed knowledge of the occult sciences to construct a Plan for the Templars[...] In his compulsively readable new novel, Eco plays with "the notion that everything might be mysteriously related to everything else," suggesting that we ourselves create the connections that make up reality. As in his best-selling The Name of the Rose, he relies on abstruse reasoning without losing the reader, for he knows how to use "the polyphony of ideas" as much for effect as for content. Indeed, with its investigation of the ever-popular occult, this highly entertaining novel should be every bit as successful as its predecessor. Previewed in Prepub Alert, LJ 6/1/89. -- Barbara Hoffert, "Library Journal"
Copyright 1989 Reed Business Information, Inc.
2. Jasper Fforde's Thursday Next 01 The Eyre Affair
From Publishers Weekly
Surreal and hilariously funny, this alternate history, the debut novel of British author Fforde, will appeal to lovers of zany genre work (think Douglas Adams) and lovers of classic literature alike. The scene: Great Britain circa 1985, but a Great Britain where literature has a prominent place in everyday life. For pennies, corner Will-Speak machines will quote Shakespeare; Richard III is performed with audience participation … la Rocky Horror and children swap Henry Fielding bubble-gum cards. In this world where high lit matters, Special Operative Thursday Next (literary detective) seeks to retrieve the stolen manuscript of Dickens's Martin Chuzzlewit. The evil Acheron Hades has plans for it: after kidnapping Next's mad-scientist uncle, Mycroft, and commandeering Mycroft's invention, the Prose Portal, which enables people to cross into a literary text, he sends a minion into Chuzzlewit to seize and kill a minor character, thus forever changing the novel. Worse is to come. When the manuscript of Jane Eyre, Next's favorite novel, disappears, and Jane herself is spirited out of the book, Next must pursue Hades inside Charlotte Bronte's masterpiece. The plethora of oddly named characters can be confusing, and the story's episodic nature means that the action moves forward in fits and starts. The cartoonish characters are either all good or all bad, but the villain's comeuppance is still satisfying. Witty and clever, this literate romp heralds a fun new series set in a wonderfully original world.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
3. Carolyn McCullough's Once A Witch
From School Library Journal
Grade 9 Up—It's hard to be the only normal one in a family in which everyone has a Talent that allows them to do such things as disappear, control the weather, read the future, or turn people to stone. Tamsin is bitter that she does not have a magical gift and dreams of the day she can move far away. So when a mysterious Scottish stranger, Alistair, shows up at her family's bookstore and assumes that the 17-year-old is her very Talented sister, Rowena, Tamsin jumps at the chance to help him find the family heirloom for which he is searching. She enlists the help of her childhood friend, Gabriel, who has recently reappeared in her life. Tamsin and Gabriel travel through time to find what sinister Alistair wants, and in doing so they will set in motion a chain of events that could mean the destruction of her family. Although Tamsin is a well-rounded character, the other people in the book are fairly one-dimensional. What is lacking in character development, though, is made up for in plot. This is an exciting book, and readers will be captivated until the very end. With a fairly easy reading level, an exciting story, and an edgier heroine (Tamsin drinks and smokes), this book is a good choice to hand to older reluctant readers.—Heather M. Campbell, formerly at Philip S. Miller Library, Castle Rock, CO ENDAnd, surprise, surprise, here comes the last contestant....
4. Stephenie Meyer's The Host
From Publishers Weekly
In this tantalizing SF thriller, planet-hopping parasites are inserting their silvery centipede selves into human brains, curing cancer, eliminating war and turning Earth into paradise. But some people want Earth back, warts and all, especially Melanie Stryder, who refuses to surrender, even after being captured in Chicago and becoming a host for a soul called Wanderer. Melanie uses her surviving brain cells to persuade Wanderer to help search for her loved ones in the Arizona desert. When the pair find Melanie's brother and her boyfriend in a hidden rebel cell led by her uncle, Wanderer is at first hated. Once the rebels accept Wanderer, whom they dub Wanda, Wanda's whole perspective on humanity changes. While the straightforward narrative is short on detail about the invasion and its stunning aftermath, it shines with romantic intrigue, especially when a love triangle (or quadrangle?!) develops for Wanda/Melanie.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Now the choice is entirely in your hands - the book with the highest number of votes wins! I am so curious about the results! The poll will last one week from today. Other books, presented here, might be reviewed later or not at all...
I am being a bit evil and thinking the host, and then you will dislike it (hopefully), and I do like those reviews ;)
ReplyDeleteBut if I am nice I say Fforde :D
Well I added The Host out of sheer spite Blodeuedd and because I enjoy writing nasty reviews! Thanks for your vote!
ReplyDeleteThe Eyre Affair!
ReplyDeleteI'm with Brooke... the Eyre Affair! I have Shades of Grey on my tbr.
ReplyDeleteUmberto Eco's Foucault's Pendulum--I liked the Eyre Affair, but not enough to read the rest of Fforde's books. Eco fascinates and intimidates me, and if you read this book I will most likely be inspired to read it to.
ReplyDeleteMy teenagers read and liked The Host, but it's never appealed to me in the least.
Ok, as nobody seems to bother with the votes in my poll here is the outcome so far:
ReplyDeleteThe Eyre Affair - 3
Foucault's Pendulum - 1
Congrats! (My blog is fast approaching it's year anniversary - there'll be a special post for that one)!
ReplyDeleteYou know I'm torn between Foucault's Pendulum and The Eyre Affair! Make that 0.5 for each, because I'd like your opinions on both.
Jane - I think you'd really like The Well of Lost Plots - set almost completely in Book World, it's very funny as well as being about the art of writing novels.
Ok,the current standing:
ReplyDeleteThe Eyre Affair - 3.5
Foucault's Pendulum - 1.5
This year my blog will be one year old too - it seems we need a bash!
Definitely up for a party, anachronist!
ReplyDeleteNow, as far as I see the current standing is:
ReplyDeleteThey Eyre Affair - 3.5
Foucault's Pendulum - 1.5
Once a Witch - 1
The Host - 1
Way to go guys, it seems to be a close race!
I would love to see what you think about the Host! Don't judge it before you've read it! That's my vote.
ReplyDeletedemitrialunetta.blogspot.com
They Eyre Affair - 3.5
ReplyDeleteFoucault's Pendulum - 1.5
Once a Witch - 1
The Host -2
Interesting indeed!
If voting is still up, I say
ReplyDeleteThe Eyre Affair!!
It sounds really good, and I always like a twist on fiction.
Jen
In the Closet With a Bibliophile
Thanks for your vote, Jen
ReplyDeleteThey Eyre Affair - 4.5
Foucault's Pendulum - 1.5
Once a Witch - 1
The Host -2
They Eyre Affair - 5.5
ReplyDeleteFoucault's Pendulum - 1.5
Once a Witch - 1
The Host -2
They Eyre Affair - 5.5
ReplyDeleteFoucault's Pendulum - 2.5
Once a Witch - 1
The Host -2
They Eyre Affair - 5.5
ReplyDeleteFoucault's Pendulum - 2.5
Once a Witch - 1
The Host -3
They Eyre Affair - 5.5
ReplyDeleteFoucault's Pendulum - 3.5
Once a Witch - 1
The Host -3
The winner is...The Eyre Affair!!! My review coming very very soon!
ReplyDelete