Saturday, 9 October 2010

Review: Hunger Games trilogy by Suzanne Collins

Review: Hunger Games trilogy (Hunger Games, Catching Fire, Mockingjay) by Suzanne Collins
Cover of Cover of The Hunger Games

Synopsis:

Somewhere in the distant future the USA are no longer a great democratic country. After a series of natural disasters it is reduced to Panem, a country consisting of 13 districts and ruled from the Capitol by a despot called President. After a bloody uprising, organized by the 13th district, the government forces decide to level the 13th district’s area to the ground; allegedly all its inhabitants are dead, the terrain is contaminated by nuclear waste and unfit to live. All the other districts are severely punished for the cooperation with the rebels – not only people are forced to vegetate as peasants and blue-collar workers on a pittance bordering sometimes starvation but also each year during a ceremony called reaping the government officials draw for two underage children (adults must work so they get off), a boy and a girl from every district; they become tributes and must take part in bloody Hunger Games, filmed and broadcast, in which you either kill or you are killed. A punishment and compulsory entertainment in one- isn’t our dear leader rather clever? The sole survivor is the winner; she/he is awarded a luxury life (like a comfortable house, some money, nice clothes and plenty of food for the victor's district) and fame but it doesn’t mean they are left to live happily ever after. It would be virtually impossible to live happily after taking part in such a nightmare as the Games.

We meet the family of Katniss Everdeen, a passionate 15-year-old girl, just before the reaping in district 12, one of the poorest but also the least important ones. She lives with her mother and Primrose, her younger sister. She must hunt to feed them although hunting is officially illegal; her father died in a mining accident and her mother doesn't earn enough. At the ceremony, her little sister is chosen by lottery to be the girl tribute. Shocked Katniss volunteers to take her place (volunteering is allowed). Her partner and competitor in the Games will be Peeta Mellark, the son of a local baker; he loves Katniss secretly but otherwise seems to be rather soft and ordinary boy without any combat training, in other words a perfect victim. He is no fool, though and knows his chances of winning are slim; his main aim is to help Katniss to survive. Katniss is not sure of his good intentions because there are no reliable allies at the Games. As we deal with a trilogy here it will be perhaps not a big spoiler if I tell you that both Katniss and Peeta survived the first Games (but I am not telling how). However, if you think it is the end of their ordeal you can't be more wrong. They provided good entertainment but also did the unthinkable, outsmarting Gamemasters and the Capitol. It is considered almost an act of defiance. They will never be left alone especially that after the Games a new rebellion is brewing in different districts. President Snow wants Katniss to prevent it happening but is it really in her power to do so? She and Peeta have no choice - they must try their utmost as their life and the life of their families and friends is on the line.

Cover via Amazon

What I liked:

Plenty. The pace of narration leaves you simply breathless, the idea behind the plot is incredibly good and original, combining Greek myths, Roman gladiator games and more contemporary events like those ugly reality shows. In my opinion the authoress brought out all the subtleties necessary for such a dark story. The series is simply un-put-downable so I was very glad I had waited a bit to be able to order all three books at once; otherwise I would be agonizing over the end constantly.

The lead character is portrayed in a truly heart-wrenching manner: as we get fond of her almost immediately we observe with ache how she struggles to save her life and sanity in quite barbaric circumstances she must face. I also liked her main partner in the Games, Peeta, very much – an intelligent boy full of kindness who simply can’t stop protecting his beloved Katniss even if he is not sure of her feelings or, in fact, anything else. What a nice surprise he wasn't a vampire ;).


Last but not least, I found the description of the Capitol people and the rebels very real indeed: we don’t have here good guys vs. bad guys cliché but on every side we are presented with different shades of evil. Some of the rebels would certainly fit the ugly Capitol without any problem and some of Capitol inhabitants are not bad at all.

What I didn’t like:

Cover via Amazon
I have no intention to pick holes in an undeniably brilliant series but I would like mention two things I didn’t like in these books.

First, the fact that we deal here with another romantic trio (Katniss, Gale and Peeta) I found simply silly. I must admit this kind of mannerism in YA literature, so popular nowadays, is getting on my nerves a lot. Soon enough any girl, be it a fictional character or a real person, who doesn’t have two boys vying for her attention at the same time will consider herself seriously deficient.

Second, I wonder why the character of Katniss’s mother was portrayed in such a way. I mean I don’t quite get why she did so little to help her daughter - she seems to be too busy to play an important role in her healing and finally she decides to leave unstable Katniss in the care of that emotionally scarred, unreliable drunkard, Haymitch, so practically on her own, in the ruins of her home district. I consider it rather strange, especially taking into account the fate of Prim. In my view it would have been more natural if they had stayed together, at least for some time.

The final verdict:

I do recommend this series to anyone who likes good stories told in a terrific manner. Just incredible read!
Gladiators shown on the late Roman Gladiator M...Image via Wikipedia
Enhanced by Zemanta

10 comments:

  1. I've heard of this series but not read any of it - it sounds like a good read, and it's the political background that really interests me if it's done well and is internally-consistent - but YA love triangles *yawn* would definitely put me off.

    ReplyDelete
  2. To defend this series a bit I can say that the love triangle was presented definitely better than that in "Twilight".

    ReplyDelete
  3. Tracy, the love triangle wasn't too bad. Nice review Bridget. I'm glad that you liked it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks Brooke - I am really grateful you tipped me off about these!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great reviews :D
    I am STILL waiting for my library to get book 3, sighs

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Blodeuedd, thanks for visiting and commenting! I know waiting is a drag but believe me the last book is worth it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks to your review I'm buying my daughter the first book of this trilogy as one of her Christmas pressies - we'll see how she gets on with it. (And I'll probably be reading it to her before bed, for a while anyway)

    ReplyDelete
  8. I've just finished reading the first book in the trilogy - very, very good. My daughter is also reading it and enjoying it. I'll review it once I've borrowed and read the other two books, but so far I'm very impressed.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Sorry, anachronist, but although I think the first book is really good, the second book really irritated me - it was too repetitive, and that love triangle was really starting to grate. So I'm not even tempted to try the final book in the trilogy. An interesting idea that, for me, started to run out of steam.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Oh well, a pity the second part didn't work for you, Tracy. You never know with these YA novels and you are too demanding a reader (in a positive sense). Love triangles suck. However, I do encourage you to try the third one. NO MORE triangles and it is a bit different, with far more adult undertones.

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for stopping by - I always appreciate if you share your thoughts!

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.